Dartford Science and Technology College

Dartford TC > History > A Level History >
A Level History Discussion Forum - To what extent were Peel's domestic and financial reforms 1841-46 a success? (24 marks)

Tools

Linear View Threaded View Order by Ascending date - Click to toggle Spacer Topic Stats

To what extent were Peel's domestic and financial reforms 1841-46 a success? (24 marks)

Mr Walker(DART_walkera)  20 Nov 2011 09:44
Key reforms to cover

Reinstatement of Income tax

Free trade reforms - reduction of duties

Bank Charter Act

Companies Act

Factory Act and Mines Act

Railways Act

Repeal of the Corn Laws
 

Info Post
Natasha Champion(Dart_06ChaNat) 

21 Nov 2011 17:16  

Post 1

During the years 1841 and 1846 Robert peel made some very successful reforms that really improved the lives of many people and also the economy of Britain. When peel came to power with the conservatives, he faced many problems. One in ten people were in poverty throughout the UK even though the country was thought to have a rich economy. The government was also in major debt of over £2 million and the rise of Chartism was a threat to the middle class people. However, over the five years that peel was in power he made some very good changes that improved the domestic and financial problems that our country was faced with.chemas-microsoft-comSurprisedfficeSurprisedffice" />

There were many reforms that peel made that were successful and a lot of them helped to gain control over the financial problem. The reinstatement of income taxes was one of the main changes that helped the government decrease their debt. Since 1816 tax had been put on heavy duty products like bread and candles. This was affecting the working class the most as they did not have enough money to buy lots of these products, however in 1842 peel decided to introduce income taxes to people that earned over £150 per year and got rid of taxes on every day products. This improved the lives of most of the working class population and the government paid off their debt and made the British economy more trust worthy.

Along with the reinstatement of income tax there were other acts that peel introduced that were successful; this included the bank charter act in 1844. Before this act was made banks could issue paper bank notes with no limit on the account. This meant the if companies got in to difficulties; investors lost their money and could not repay the banks. Due to this banks would often collapse due to insufficient gold reserves to back the paper currency. Robert peel came to the conclusion that the economy could only be expanded if the currency were stable. The bank charter act made sure that there was a limit on the amount of money banks where aloud to issue and also said that if any new banks that were made, they were not allowed to distribute money at all. This gave the bank of England greater control over the banknote issue, as there had to be a gold reserve of the same amount in the bank of England before it can be issued.

Both of these reforms helped the financial trouble that England was in during 1841 to 1846. Along with the financial difficulties there were some domestic problems too.

The mines act in 1842 responded to the appalling working conditions of the mines. It stated that all children under ten years old were no longer aloud to work underground and that women were also forbidden from working underground. This was a very good reform for all the women and children at the time as these industries were extremely dangerous and deaths were common.

Along with this came the factory act in 1844 which was mostly the work of the home secretary, James Graham. It reduced the working hours for children under 13 and recommended that there should be some safety improvements in factories. The last of the domestic reforms that were a success was the railways act in 1844 which aimed to regulate the activity of the railway companies and also making sure that the passengers were safe at all times.

Over all, the extents of all Robert Peels reforms during 1841 to 1846 were very successful and improved the lives of many people and made the country’s economy more trusted by foreign importers. After all the good changes that Peel made to the country, it’s a shame that when he decided to repeal the corn laws, the cabinet split and Robert Peel was made to resign!
17/24 B
www. a very clear and informative start which gives an answer to the question straight away which is excellent practice. Good K&U of many of Peel's reforms - nicely related to question to support your argument
ebi you need a detailed section of the CLs as this was the reform that wasn't so overwhelmingly successful for Peel - without it your answer lacks balance and therefore can't get to the top level

Emma Cooper(Dart_05CooEmm) 

22 Nov 2011 10:43  

Post 2
To what extent were Peel’s domestic and financial reforms 1841-46 a success? (24 marks)

 

The Domestic and Financial Reforms of Peel’s government were largely successful. When Peel came to power in 1841, he faced many problems. The most important was the huge national deficit left by the Whigs. This led to Peel reintroducing Income Tax in 1841. This was introduced as a temporary measure of three years, however after its success the Tax remained. The Income Tax was taken from everyone who earned over £150. This was a controversial move, but a successful one because the National Deficit was soon paid off.

Another important Act was the Mines Bill, introduced by Lord Shaftesbury in 1842. This removed women and children from the horrific conditions of the mines. The bill was introduced by Lord Shaftesbury after a report on child labour was written. This social reform was a long term solution to child and vulnerable women labour. Although a Conservative Reform it is questionable how much Peel did to pass the bill. The improvement was a success; however the credit for this reform should be Lord Shaftesbury because he investigated the conditions of the workers and forced the bill through Parliament.

In addition, following the success of the Mines Bill of 1842, a factory reform was soon introduced, as an extension of the Factory Reform Act introduced by the Whigs in 1833. The Factory Act of 1833 minimised the hours children over nine could work and banned all under the age of nine from working, but did not have any effect on the adults. The reform of 1844, introduced change to the adult female working day, by reducing their hours to twelve. Children also benefitted once again from this reform as their hours were reduced to six and a half. The workers were also entitled to one and a half hours for meals. This was a partially successful reform, because hours were reduced, and safety around machines were set up, however once again the Ten Hour Movement campaigned by Lord Shaftesbury was rejected. Adults were still expected to work twelve hour days which was unacceptable and tiring.

The most important reform was the Bank Charter Act. This Economic Reform was a long term change, as it allowed the currency to stabilise. This was achieved by giving The Bank of England the role of issuing notes to the value of £14 million. Anything beyond that figure had to be covered by Gold reserves. Having this important role with the Bank of England meant smaller banks could no longer issue money, which had previously damaged the economy, with too much money being printed which meant the value of the currency was reduced. This was successful because the value of the money went up, meaning the economy was back in a stable place.

Free Trade was an important factor for Robert Peel. The Budgets of 1842 and 1845 swept a large amount of the remaining duties away. Over six hundred duties were scrapped and hundreds more were significantly reduced. Export duties were reduced and this helped the working class as they could now afford to pay for essentials such as cotton, meat and potatoes. The Budgets were a great success for Peel and the Conservatives as they worked exactly how he hoped they would. Trade improved dramatically and unemployment fell. The most important change was food became cheaper as imports increased and duties were either removed or reduced.

Although many of the reforms introduced by Peel was hugely successful, one reform was so controversial that it resulted in a division in the Conservative Government and ended in Peel resigning from his post as Prime Minister. There were a number of factors that are discussed by Historians as to why the Corn Laws were repealed in 1846. Firstly, the outbreak of the Irish Potato Famine, led to Peel realising that in order to save the starving Irish, he needed to make imports cheaper as the Irish relied on the imports they were receiving. Secondly, the success of the budgets in 1842 and 1845, led to further reductions in tariff prices because they stimulated industry and reduced unemployment. Finally the appeal of the Anti Corn Law League led by Cobden and Bright campaigned using propaganda and mass meetings. They viewed the Corn Laws introduced in 1815 as ‘a moral evil of society’. They wanted the law to be scrapped and cheaper imports to be introduced. The pressure from all of the above factors led Peel to repeal the Corn Laws in 1846.

To conclude, Peel’s reforms were largely successful, however many of the reforms were introduced as they catered for all classes and this risked his popularity in his party. This was eventually his downfall, as he repealed the Corn Laws to benefit the working class and starving Irish. The Social reforms he introduced were successful, however The Factory Reform of 1844, could have been more beneficial by reducing the hours adults had to work. The Economic reforms were hugely successful because, The Bank Charter Act stabilised the economy, the reintroduction of Income Tax removed the National Deficit left by the Whigs and the Budgets of 1842 and 1845 removed and reduced hundreds of duties on necessary goods.
 
20/24 A/B
www. This is a really good effort Cooperman! The structure is good - K&U very good - I like the answer in the first line and the conclusion is excellent
ebi - I still want you to refer more explicitly to the title and your argument after each reform - you are still leaving it to the examiner infer your argument

George Money(DART_06mongeo) 

22 Nov 2011 19:26  

Post 3
Boo, mwa hahahahhahaha 3 word of 1000 i think its a bit long

To what extent were Peel’s domestic and financial reforms 1841-46 a success? (24 marks)
 
Peels domestic and financial reforms between 1841 and 1846 where a success, they helped the working class but more importantly helped Britain out of its defecit. Peel was faced by many problems when he came into power and by the time he was out he had sorted out all of the problems he had faced, the only problem was by sorting out many of these problems at the Upper and Middle class's expense it became his downfall.
 
Probably the most important reforms that Peel introduced was the reinistatement of income tax 1841, this had only been used during the Napoleonic war to finance it but Peel brought it back to attempt to get Britain out of its deficit which he said would take three years. Peel only put this tax on people who earned more than £150 a year, 7 pence per pound was taken from them and in no time Britains massive deficit had been payed off. As this proved extremerly successful Peel kept it and since then it has never been abolished. The only problem Peel faced with this move was the fact it was only the rich people that where taxed which therefore meant that he was disliked by the middle and upper classes.
 
Another reform which proved to be a success for Peel was the reduction of duties on many many products coming into Britain, because Britian was now out of debt and was starting to pick itself back up Peel could afford to reduce duties on over 700 products. This therefore led to the working class being able to afford to eat and so Peel became very popular with the average working person, this made this reform very successful as it really helped a lot of people.
 
Another of the most important Refrms Peel introduced was the Bank Charter Act, this act introduced a stable currency to Britain with the Bank of England running the new banking system. The Bank of England kept a reserve of gold in its vaults, this made sure that the new paper notes kept their value as only a cetain amount where printed off and other banks where not allowed to issue this currency, by introducing this the whole of Britain had a stable currency and a stable economy. By having a paper currency which was stable other countries thought that if they would make an investment it would be in Britain as they knew that their money would be safe, by doing this it meant that Britain was then flooded by more investors etc which really helped the country boom.
 
At this time Peel had become more confident, he had basically all of the working class supporting him and so started to introduce more and more refoms which actually benefitted them, one of these such reforms was the Factories and and Mining Act. The Factory Act redueced the hours so that women could work only 12 hours a day, the Act also reduced childrens working hours to 6 and a half for children under 13. Lastly the Act gave everyone at factories one and half hours to have lunch. This larerly benefitted children and women in the wroking class but didnt really help the men, it also angered the middle class who where employing these people as they vcouldnt get as much work from them. The Mining Act stopped women and children under the age of 10 working in the mines, this was successful for the working class yet again but for the middle class children where favoured for working in the small tunnels as they where nimble. Overall these two acts where partly successful as they helped the working class but angered the middle class.
 
The Railways Act was next in Peels line of reforms, this Act was actually the work of William Gladstone president of the Board of Trade. The Act was used to regulate th working of the railways, the Act ensured that at least one train should stop at all stations and that the price should be around 1p a mile for the public. This reform was pretty successful as it made the railways really stable like the banking system was now.
 
The last reform introduced by Robert Peel was the repeal of the Corn Laws, Peel scrapped the corn laws so that it could be brtought into the country and sold at any price, this therefore meant that the cost of Bread etc went down which made Peel extremerly hated by the middle class as they where all land owners and by taking away the Corn Laws they didnt make as much money. This reform actually split his party in half, it was now divided into two halves and so this ended up in Peel resigning from his post.  There are many arguements into why Peel actually got rid of the Corn Laws, one being that he wanted to help the Irish as they had a potato famine, another being that he wanted to rid of the Anti Corn League and another being that he was a strong supporter of free trade which can be reflected in his reforms. All we can gather is that he introduced this reform but was extremerly disliked for it.
 
In conclusion i think that Peels reforms where largely a success, the Bank Charter Act brought the economy stable, the introduction of income tax got rid of the deficit and made the duties on many products lower greately helping the working class. Peel did actually sort out every problem he faced during his time in Government but unfortunately he went one reform too far by getting rid of the Corn Laws, this was eventually his downfall as he angered the middle class and upper class even more and so was very hated by them. Other than getting rid of the Corn Laws his reforms where very successfull and really benefitted the country.
 
 
 19/24 B/A
www. another well written and thoughtful response George - your exam technique is certainly moving in the right direction, V Good K&U of all the major reforms and a sustained answer to the question set emerges.
ebi - you miss a few opportunities to develop your argument - esp. relating to the short term and long term consequences of the CL repeal. You might have reviewed the problems of 1841 in your conclusion - to what extent had Peel successfully solved therm?

Amber Beach(Dart_06BeaAmb) 

23 Nov 2011 10:18  

Post 4

Peel’s significant domestic and financial reforms were greatly successful between the years 1841-56.Not only did they benefit working class people but they also in some ways highlighted the first evidence for Toryism adapting into conservatism, The first most dominant piece of proof for the success of the reforms were the way in which they managed to get the country out of its £2 million pound deficit. The lowering of tariffs, reform of taxation and stabilization of the currency led to the reduction of the national debt, this was a factor that would alleviate much stress from Britain and would prompt a new growth in the economy leading to a bright future for Britain.

Peel had the task of getting the country back on track after the large deficit it had been left ion by the former Whigs. Peel made his first step towards national reform with the reduction of duties, Peel acknowledged that the less duties on these essential goods, the more the working class would be able to buy and this therefore would lead to greater profit. Peel realised that this reform on duties would over time generate greater revenue but he was adamant on eliminating the national deficit, with this motif in mind he took one of the most controversial approaches towards generating more money and reintroduced income tax. It was to be collected at a rate of 7pence in every £150. This was a largely significant reform that angered people temporarily, yet was imposed as a temporary measure that would be taken away within three years of its introduction; this however was a pledge that didn’t stick. These tow reforms were directed towards saving the country from its deficit and they were indeed entirely successful.

The Bank Charter act of 1844 was another reform introduced by peel that would regulate the activity of banks and limit note issue by banks. By doing so |Peel managed to create one of the most reliable banks throughout the world, the Bank of England was trusted by foreign countries and the British pound became one of the most prosperous currency in the world. This regulation on bank issue also meant that the value of money was kept at a high standard and prosperity within Britain remained. This was an important reform introduced by Peel as it kept Britain prosperous. Another reform that supported the prosperity and the organisation of financial Britain was the companies act, this act stated that all companies were to keep accounts of their generated income; this then led to further organisation and prosperity of Britain. how?

Peel was also influenced by the views of humanitarianism and with Christian influence and the well being of the working class people in mind, he introduced two additional acts that would benefit the working class entirely. The Mines Act 1842 prevented females and boys under the age of ten from working within the terrible mining conditions. This would have had a short term impact on the overall income of working class families but for the long run it benefitted the working class, it signified how the government had the well being of the working class people in mind. The factory act in 1844 was also another act that had the well being of the working class in mine, with the basis of the original factory act of 1833 peel adapted this act and attempted to introduce the 10 hour day, yet this was unsuccessful. Peel’s reforms benefitted both society and the people within; it seemed that finally the working class could identify real reform.

With Peel’s new found reputation for free trade and effective reforms, there was one act that remained to hang over Britain, this was the Corn Laws, these outdated laws were in real need of being repealed, and with the influence of the anti corn law league, and the stress of the Irish Potato famine, Peel was in a position where the positives of abolishing the corn laws outweighed the negatives. With the support of many Whigs also, in 1846 the repeal of the corn laws was passed, this was one of the most significant pivotal points within peels career as Prime Minister, it marked the real transformation that Britain had undergone and in comparison to the days of real distress in 1815, 1840’s Britain had a bright air about it.  -- develop this - what do you mean?

Overall, peels reforms were highly significant, this was a man who once resented change yet now was gaining respect through his ideas of free trade and financial growth. The repeal of the corn laws in 1846 was a real summary for the success and the stress that peel alleviated from Britain. Although his reforms may have seemed controversial, he challenged the expectations of the political system and therefore transformed Britain forever, The Repeal of the Corn Laws led to a divide in his party between the ultra Tories and the liberal conservatives, yet Peel still held the well being of the country in his mind.
 
19/24 B/A
www. good planning and v good K&U and a priaseworthy attempt to sustain an answer to the question set
ebi the argument could be improved by outling success criteria at the start of the essay - or did he solve all the problems he faced? Were all the reforms a success short term and long term? successful for whom?Your conclusion is the main place where you need to do this as at the moment it doesn't quite do justice the quality of the rest of the essay

Marnie Blackmore(Dart_06BlaMar) 

23 Nov 2011 10:30  

Post 5

To what extent were Peel's domestic and financial reforms 1841-46 a success? (24 marks)chemas-microsoft-comSurprisedfficeSurprisedffice" />

 

Overall, Peel’s reforms were domestically and financially very successful. Peel came to power in 1841 with the conservatives; peel unfortunately was faced with masses of problems caused by the Whigs before. The most crucial problem to be sold was the national debt left by the Whig party. There was famine in chemas-microsoft-comSurprisedfficeConfusedmarttags" />ountry-region wConfusedt="on">t="on">Irelandountry-region> therefore people were starving as they could not afford food. Followed by the political pressure of splits in the party, radical threat by chartists and Peels resistance to reform and this was just all before he started! Peel clearly had a lot to do and he done this with diligence.

 

Firstly, the national debt that the Whigs left caused an unsettlement for the upper class due to Peel’s reintroduction of income tax for the rich, which had previously been abolished in 1816 by Lord Liverpool. 7 pence in the pound on incomes over £150 per annum was decided. Peel hoped that this would not only absorb the countries huge debt but also turn the country around into disposable surplus. Initially it was planned as a temporary measure and only meant to last 3 years however, Peel managed to persuade parliament to renew it for another 3 years – however no other government since has been able to afford to abandon the tax. This reform was extremely successful and arguably the most successful of them all. explain why in more detail

 

Secondly, another financial reform of lowering of the tariffs. Peel was strongly influenced by a group of northern industrialists calling themselves the t="on">t="on">Manchester school, and came to believe they were stifling the British industry – furthermore, some argue that Peel was all for free trade and liberalism. Peel’s actions caused attraction from foreign countries as they no longer held a grudge against paying a tariff for trade. Peels actions made the economy boom, influencing free trade and more trade. Also, Peel believed that by doing g this it would make the cost of living cheaper and would provide more jobs for the public and would overall benefit the working class. you need more K&U of free trade reforms here

 

The bank charter act of 1844 was a huge success also due to it causing a massive increase in the British economy as well as attracting foreign traders due to them trusting the British economy and knowing that their investments are safe or true. Peel aimed to restore confidence in a system, as previously banks issued notes with no limit on the account. If companies got into difficulties, investors lost their money and could not repay the banks. Some banks, having over issued notes would then collapse due to insufficient gold reserves to back the paper currency. Peel also believed the economy would expand if the banking system was stable, Peel was correct the economy boomed and supported the other financial reforms. All of these helped the British economy and has kept it stable up until even today! The three rules of the charter were no new banks were allowed to issue notes and existing banks has limits on issuing notes; furthermore, the bank of England was given huge responsibility and control over banknote issue, which was linked to bullion reserves and securities. The action proved highly successful and was the starting point for the modern methods used to control an economy – this also cause mid-Victorian security.

 

In addition, a domestic reform the 1842 mines act. This was a responsive action to the dangerous working conditions revealed in the report of the Royal Commission Peel has set up. The act stated that all children younger than 10 were forbidden to work underground as well as women, this reform seemed to be a common sense response to a dangerous industry were deaths were overwhelmingly common. However, this was not a crucial reform it was a huge step towards health and safety and it kept Christian humanitarians quiet.

Continuing is the passage of the factory act of 1844 and this was largely the work of the home secretary, Sir James Graham. It introduced set working hours for those under 13 and set recommended safety requirements in factories, such as fencing of machinery. Some believe that Peel was less interested in the social reforms and didn’t have much input in them. Such as the report in the mines act not being his actions, as well as the main work being done by Sir James Graham. However, this could be seen as an unfair statement to a genuine effort to improve conditions in the mines and factories.

Furthermore, the railway act of 1844 was the work of president of the board of trade, William Gladstone. This act aimed to regulate the activities of the new railway companies, as well as safe guarding the interests of passengers. The act also instituted the ‘parliamentary’ train. This required each railway company to put on at least one train per day, which stopped at every station on the line.

 

In conclusion, Peels reforms were a huge success and transferred the British economy from being in huge debt to economic surplus with his amazing financial reforms. Furthermore, Peel’s social reforms also proved to be effective due to the mines, factory and railways acts radicals such as chartists kept quiet due to nothing to complain about. ountry-region wConfusedt="on">t="on">Britainountry-region> was the wealthiest and strongest economy in the world and was trusted worldwide also. Overall, Peels reforms cause massive relaxation in the country causing mid-Victorian stability and the abolition of poverty in ountry-region wConfusedt="on">Irelandountry-region> as well as ountry-region wConfusedt="on">t="on">Britainountry-region>.
17/24 B
www. well planned - mainly good K&U with only a few ommissions - regular reference to title could to see and this is certainly a successful answer to the question set
ebi the ommission of the CLS is  a bit of a problem as it robs the essay of some balance which could otherwise have been achieved - the only rreform arguably not very successful for him in the short term

Danielle Lynch(DART_06lyndan) 

24 Nov 2011 11:57  

Post 6
To What extent were peel's domestic and financial reforms 1841 - 46 a success .
The years 1841 to 1846 were peel's domestic and financial reforms ,they were largely succsessful .Peel came to power in 1841 and faced many promblems .The most important reform was the national deficit .This led peel to re - introduce income tax in 1841 .This was very successfull and the tax remained .People had to pay income tax if they were on an income over £150 per year .This however should have only lasted 3 years but after a while the national deficit was paid off .
 
Another thing peel introduced that was successful was the bank charter act in 1844 .This meant eventually only the bank of england issued notes and controlled the amount of currency in circualation .This gave the bank of england more control over the banknotes issued .This was hugely succsesful because it meant money was going up meaning the economy was improving .
 
Moreover the mines bill of 1842 ,a futher step forward but only one inspector for the whole country .The factory act 1844 limits to working 10 hours for children and banned all under age of nine working but did not have any effect on adults .
 
Income taxes was one of the main changes that helped the governement decrease their debt .1816 tax had been put on heavy duty products like bread .The working class could not afford this .So in 1842 anyone who earned £150 per year got rid of taxes on everyday products .
 
The railyways act 1844 was another one of peels reforms .The act limits working to 10 hours .The act aimed to regulate the working of the railywyas .This act was pretty stable as it made the railyways stable .The appeal of the anti corn laws league led by bright and cobden , they viewed that the corn lawsin 1815 was seen
as a moral evil of society .This made peel then decide to set aside the corn laes in 1846 .
 
In conclusion peels reforms were succesful and the reforms helped all classes .The most important act by far was the bank charter act this astablished the economy and got rid of the national deficit led by the whigs .
 
11/24 D
 
www you cover some of reforms in a reasonable way and have tried to use your K and U to answer the question explicity
ebi - you need quite a lot more depth knowledge of each reform and you ahve missed out the Corn law repeal. It would be good for you to read and take notes from the section in the textbooks and from my webpage lesson and then come back to develop this answer

Samuel Kalejaiye(DART_06samuelkalejaiye) 

24 Nov 2011 14:08  

Post 7
Samuel K

Robert Peel's multiple reforms in the period 1841 to 1846, are seen as a success to a great extent both domestically and finacially/ecconomicaly. This is proven in the many reforms he made such as the Bank Charter Act of 1844. This act enabled the Bank Of  chemas-microsoft-comSurprisedfficeConfusedmarttags" />t="on">ountry-region wConfusedt="on">Englandountry-region> to be the nations primary and most powerfull bank, while the act also limited and restircted the powers of other banks which had been one of the causes for the ecconomic mess the country was in at the time. The power was given to The Bank Of England to be the bank that issued new notes (whuch caused the ecconomy to be more orderly) and also hold reserves of gold which represented paper money. It was this that stabalizes the ecconomy and strengthened the Pound, to the point where it became the most strongest currency in the world. This act, (led by Peel) also provided what is no known today as 'Mid Victorian Stability' which was era of prosperity in ountry-region wConfusedt="on">t="on">Britainountry-region> which lasted until the late 1870's. This partly shows that a reform by Peel worked to a great extent, that it provided an ecconomy which had been previosuly with a huge defecit, now having the strongest currency in the world. This was long and short term reform as it influenced the ecconomy at time and has been adopted by many other ecconomies.This can be seen as success to a great extent.

 

Another reform that shows that Peel's reforms had great depth and were a success was the reinroduction of income tax. This was were income tax was inroduced again as the Government has a huge defecit to face and huge depth which threatened to paralyze the ecconomy. Peel introduced the income tax to raise capital to clear this dept and to get the eccomomy moving again and it did work. Also, apart from the reintroduction of income tax, duties were removed from over 600 items during the period of 1842 - 1945, as well as duties greatly reduced on 500 items. This was a good reform as it helped riase the money needed for the goverment to survive with the income tax, but then helped the working class in paticualr with duties removed or reduced as they can afford to put foods on thier table. Peel has been quoted to say 'We need to make ountry-region wConfusedt="on">t="on">Britainountry-region> a cheaper place to live'. This reform certainly helped to do this. However, the reintroduction of income tax did upset some members of society such as Landed Aristocrats and the upper class because they thought they had worked hard for their money and should retain all of it. Theses reforms had a long term effect as icome tax is still be used 169 years on.

 

Also another reform made which looked good on the onset but caused contrevery among the upper class again, was the abolition of the Corn Laws in 1846. The Corn Laws were established in 1815 and was a artificial tax placed on things like wheat and Corn that benefited only Landed Aristorats but made buying those types of foods more expensive for the working class. By the time of the repeal there was a great famine in ountry-region wConfusedt="on">t="on">Irelandountry-region> and many have suggested that is why Peel repealed the Law. Others have argued he was a humanitarium. However, this law did not sit so well with Landed Aristocrats as it meant they would not make anyewhere as much as they did as before. The corn laws are also long lasting as they are still abolished to this present day.
 
Also, acts such as the mines act of 1842 showed commitemnet from Peel to better the living and working quality of workers and more specifally, the much younger ones. This meant that workers under 9 could not work over 10 hours. This law was inspired by Christain capaingers who argued wokrking conditions as they were, were damaging to children and could have a long lasting phycological effect on them.
 
In conclusion, evedence suggests that Peels reforms were a success to a significant effect as it provided the ecconomy with substancial funds to take it off its feet once again. Also, domestically the reforms were a success as it alowed ordinary working class citizents to ba able to afford enough foos for the familly due to relaxed duties and removals altogether on household items and foods. Many in history, will remeber the reforms for creating the 'mid victorian stabiltiy' peroid.
 
18/24 B
www. this has the makings of an outstanding answer Sam - the first half is excellent and you show an encouraging ability to reflect on and develop your argument
ebi the second half is a little rushed methinks and you are not quite so reflective or thoughtful in your comments about the reforms discussed here

Chloe Hughes(Dart_06HugChl) 

25 Nov 2011 09:09  

Post 8
  1. chemas-microsoft-comSurprisedfficeSurprisedffice" /> During the years 1841-46 Peels introduced many reforms which indeed changed the running of the economy in chemas-microsoft-comSurprisedfficeConfusedmarttags" />ountry-region wConfusedt="on">t="on">Britainountry-region> and people within it. When Peel arrived in power along with the conservatives, the current state of the economy was in trouble. The government was in a major debt crisis of £2 million. Chartism was a great threat, however once Peel had been put in power he strived to revitalize the recent government situation.
  2.  
  3. There were many reforms declared by Peel once he had reached power, which were to benefit the population of ountry-region wConfusedt="on">t="on">Britainountry-region>. The reinstatement of income tax was a beneficial reform, it gave everyone 7p in the 1£ for everyone earning over £150 a year. This was to help towards solving the deficit and major debt that the government were left in after the Whigs lost control. The main reason for the deficit was the inefficient taxation system in place. Proving Peel made some successful reforms.
  4.  
  5. The Mines Act of 1842 was another reform produced by Peel and the conservatives to help the worker down in the mines by reducing their working hours almost by half, giving them less time to work in the mines and also stopped women and boys under ten being allowed to even work in such conditions. Peel’s reforms were based on helping the majority of the population.
  6.  
  7. The Factory Act of 1844 was another reform proposed by Shaftesbury, which lead to success as it benefited young children and in general the working class and their families. It also reduced female working hours to 12 a day and the hours of children reduced to 6.5 from 9. Shaftsbury attempted to get the 10 hour day for all adults however this was ejected by Peel.
  8.  
  9. The Banking Charter Act of 1844 was unstable any bank could issue notes with any face value, without the gold reserves to support the value. The features of the Act included no new banks could issue notes; existing banks were also restricted in issuing notes. The Bank of England could issue notes to the value of £14 million anything beyond that figure had to be covered by gold reserves. This was a very successful reform eventually on thee Bank of England issued notes and controlled the amount of currency and circulation. The £ became stable and t="on">t="on">London the monetary centre of the world.
  10. 14/24 C/D
  11. www. good sensible comments about many of Peel's reforms and you answer the question in a sensible way
  12. ebi you need to begin to reflect a little more on explaining how and why they were successful and successful for whom. Also you have missed out the CLs which robs your essay of balance
 
 

ww


 
Login
Forgotten password?
Having trouble logging in?
 





 Copyright 2011 Dartford Technology College
Contact the College